Year Two of the Literary Harlem Renaissance — The Fault Lines Surface


Year One, 1925, promised that the explosion of Negro writing and the evident talent of the writers coming to the fore would justify the civil-rights-by-copyright optimism of the Elders who maneuvered an apparatus of magazines, competitions, and connections to the white power structure. In this regard, Locke’s anthology, The New Negro, was aspirational, annunciatory, and a proof of concept combined.
The unity of Black writing it presaged was short-lived and illusory. Year Two laid down the principal fault line: respectability politics vs. candor. That line cut through the middle of the younger generation as often as it separated the Elders from their protégés. The Black literary establishment, with its control of magazines and their associated prize contests, continued to promote its anointed favorites (Countee Cullen, Langston Hughes, Zora Neale Hurston) as well as discover new talents (Dorothy West, Arna Bontemps). But among some of the laureates themselves a revolt was brewing.
A young Langston Hughes, the apotheosis, it seemed, of the validity of the Black literary mechanisms, published his first book of poetry, The Weary Blues, in January of 1926. The volume was warmly received by the African American gatekeepers with one important exception. Countee Cullen, literary lion of respectability politics, wrote in his review, “There is too much emphasis here on strictly Negro themes; and this is probably an added reason for my coldness toward the jazz poems.”
Cullen's discomfort was part of a wider argument playing out that same year. When George Schuyler published "The Negro-Art Hokum" in The Nation that June, dismissing the very idea of a distinct Negro art, Hughes answered him in the same pages with "The Negro Artist and the Racial Mountain,” one of the earliest manifestoes of a Black aesthetic. His opening paragraph skewered the unnamed “most promising of the young Negro poets” handily.
You don’t want to be a Negro poet, just a poet? That means you want to be white. Which is too bad because you’ve cut yourself off from all the good Negro stuff: jazz, the blues, the vernacular, street life, Bessie Smith. He ends with a declaration of Black authenticity that broadcast the split in Black writing on the national stage. “We younger Negro artists who create now intend to express our individual dark-skinned selves without fear or shame.”
Then Carl Van Vechten, who had already been championing those very aspects of African American culture to a white readership in Vanity Fair, really muddied the waters with the publication of his novel Nigger Heaven that October. The book introduced Harlem, both high and low, to white America in all its complexity and contradiction. In spite of the fact that it was a bad novel, sensationalistic, and contained much deadwood argumentation that barely passed as dialogue, it was a runaway success and outsold every other book coming out of the Renaissance by a wide margin.
The title alone affronted much of the Black community. The harshest condemnation came, unsurprisingly, from the advocates of respectability politics: Du Bois called it a blow in the face, and Cullen's break with Van Vechten over the book reportedly kept the two men from speaking for fourteen years. Hughes, for his part, defended the book, but his position went beyond friendship. Van Vechten had lifted the lyrics to “Shake That Thing” without permission or attribution. When he was threatened with a lawsuit on the occasion of the novel’s fifth (!) printing, he called on Hughes to save his ass. Hughes obliged in an all-night session, replacing the pirated lyrics with his own compositions.
Hughes was also associated with “the Niggerati,” to use Hurston’s witty label, a group of younger writers whose open revolt against respectability writing was enshrined in the November issue of Fire!! Devoted to Younger Negro Artists. Wallace Thurman, the fiery outsider iconoclast, had cast himself as leader of these insurgents and had corralled two of the previously championed laureates – Hughes and Hurston – into his camp. Thurman was determined to shake things up and made sure that his journal contained stories on such taboo subjects as prostitution, bisexuality, and interracial relationships. Nugent’s bare-breasted women and Douglas’s satirical drawings were scarcely less provocative.
With no institutional infrastructure and, at best, tepid support from the literary gatekeepers, Fire!! was doomed to financial failure and early oblivion. Yet because it was gorgeously designed, this single issue was one of the best things to come out of the Harlem Renaissance – a fact recognized some 80 years later. It made almost no impression at the time.
(The other 1926 literary contribution of enduring value, Eric Walrond’s collection of Caribbean stories, Tropic Death, was equally without ramification. Walrond was no outsider: Locke anthologized him and Charles S. Johnson of Opportunity magazine mentored him. Most of the stories in Tropic Death had already appeared in the same magazines that were championing Cullen and Hughes. Both white and Black editors recognized the originality and quality of his writing. But the Caribbean content of the collection was too far outside the geographical — Harlem — and ideological — U.S.-centric — frame of the movement to make an impact.)
Fire!! was still a shot across the bow. Those Niggerati associates who later published in mainstream presses continued their quest for candor. But the exponents of respectability writing were far from silenced. Year Three would see the two poets on either side of the fault line go head-to-head.
— Dr. Robert Philipson
Read more about Dr. Robert Philipson's personal connection to this foray in I Live the Heterosexual Lie — Again.
SHOGA FILMS is a non-profit production and education company. Please consider making a donation to help fund our efforts.




Comments